Appraisal and mediation both help you resolve a disagreement with your insurer without going to court, but they solve different problems. Appraisal settles the dollar amount of a covered loss, and its result is binding. Mediation is a facilitated negotiation that can cover broader disagreements, and you do not have to accept the outcome. If your insurer agrees the storm damaged your roof but offers too little to fix it, appraisal is usually the tool. If the fight is about whether the damage is covered at all, appraisal is the wrong tool.
TL;DR
- Appraisal decides how much a covered loss is worth. Each side hires an appraiser, and an umpire settles any difference. The result is binding.
- Mediation is a meeting with a neutral third party who helps both sides reach a deal. It is non-binding unless you sign a settlement.
- Coverage disputes (is this damage covered, does an exclusion apply) generally do not belong in appraisal. Courts decide those.
- Deadlines and rules come from your policy and your state. Read the appraisal clause before you act.
- A documented roof estimate from a qualified inspector is the strongest thing you can bring to either process.
Table of Contents
- The core difference in plain terms
- What appraisal can and cannot decide
- How the appraisal process works
- How mediation works
- The choice: which one for your situation?
- Evidence wins both processes
- Common mistakes
- Why we start with the inspection
- Get your roof scope in writing
- FAQ
- Sources
The core difference in plain terms
Think of appraisal as a valuation contest and mediation as a negotiation.
In an appraisal, nobody argues about whether your policy applies. The question is only the number: what does it cost to repair or replace the damage? Two appraisers, one chosen by you and one by the insurer, each prepare an estimate. If they cannot agree, a third person called an umpire decides. The Texas Department of Insurance describes this process as binding on both parties once the umpire rules.
In mediation, a neutral mediator sits with you and the insurer and works toward a compromise. Florida's Department of Financial Services describes its program as an informal meeting with a certified, neutral mediator, and says none of the parties has to accept the outcome.
| Appraisal | Mediation | |
|---|---|---|
| What it decides | The dollar amount of a covered loss | Any part of the dispute both sides want to settle |
| Who decides | Two appraisers, or one appraiser plus an umpire | You and the insurer, helped by a neutral mediator |
| Binding? | Yes | No, until you sign a settlement |
| Coverage questions | Generally not decided here | Can be discussed |
| Typical cost to you | Your appraiser plus half the umpire | Varies by state and program |
| Best for | Your estimate and the insurer's estimate are far apart | Several issues are tangled together |
What appraisal can and cannot decide
Appraisal answers a narrow question. According to one law firm guide to the appraisal clause, it is best suited to disagreements over scope and estimate differences, and it does not resolve coverage denials, exclusions, policy interpretation or causation disputes.
The American Bar Association's insurance coverage newsletter says the same thing from the legal side: appraisal panels typically decide valuation and amount-of-loss issues, cannot interpret the policy, and leave coverage disputes to courts. It also warns that unclear instructions to the panel about what kind of value is being sought can lead a court to refuse to confirm the award.
What does that mean on a roof claim? Here are two examples.
Example 1: a pricing gap. Hail hit your roof. The insurer agrees the claim is covered and writes an estimate for repairing one slope. Your inspector documents damage across the whole roof and estimates a full replacement. Nobody disputes that hail is covered. The disagreement is over scope and cost. That is an appraisal dispute.

Example 2: a coverage dispute. The insurer says the damage is old wear and not storm damage, and denies the claim. Here the question is whether the loss is covered, so an appraisal alone will not fix it. This is where mediation, a conversation with an attorney, or a formal complaint to your state insurance department comes in.
The Roof Appraisal Clause guide on our blog walks through how this plays out on a roof claim specifically.
How the appraisal process works
Your policy's appraisal clause sets the steps. Most follow the same pattern, which the Texas Department of Insurance lays out:
- Demand appraisal in writing. Check your policy for a deadline. Some policies set one, and missing it can cost you the option.
- Each side names an appraiser. Many clauses require the appraiser to be competent and disinterested. Washington's auto appraisal statute, for example, uses those words and sets 10 days to pick appraisers and 30 days to complete appraisals for policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2026. Home policies in your state will have their own timelines.
- The appraisers choose an umpire. If they cannot agree, many policies let a judge pick one.
- Each appraiser estimates the loss. If the two numbers match, the matter is done. If not, the umpire decides.
- An agreement binds both sides. Typically, agreement by any two of the three is enough.
Who pays
As a rule, you pay your own appraiser and split the umpire's cost with the insurer. Texas says the policyholder is responsible for their own appraiser and half of the umpire's expenses. Florida's consumer advocate adds that an appraiser may charge a percentage of the amount awarded or a set fee, so ask about the fee structure before you hire anyone.
Timing matters
Deadlines come from your policy and your state. Texas offers a useful example of how they can bite: for windstorm claims through its state insurer, the TDI notes that some policies give only 60 days after the insurer's estimate to demand appraisal, while newer replacement-cost policies allow far longer to complete repairs. That is Texas, not South Carolina. Your own policy language is what counts.
One more caution from a legal source: invoking appraisal too early, while the real dispute is coverage, can reduce your leverage or delay resolution. Sort out which kind of dispute you have first.
How mediation works
Mediation puts both sides in one room, in person or virtually, with a neutral person whose job is to find common ground. The mediator does not rule on who is right.
Because it is non-binding, you can walk away if the offer is not acceptable. Once you sign a settlement, though, it matters. Under Florida's statute, a signed settlement binds you and acts as a release of the claims presented unless you rescind it within three business days and have not cashed the check. That cooling-off right is a Florida rule, and other states may not give you one.
Mediation programs differ by state
Florida runs a state program for residential property claims. Its insurers pay the $350 conference cost and the conference must happen within 21 calendar days of the mediator's assignment. Eligibility requires a dispute of $500 or more after the deductible. These details are specific to Florida, and they show how much the rules vary. In South Carolina, ask the state Department of Insurance, or read your policy and any notice letters, to learn what dispute options exist and who pays.
United Policyholders, a nonprofit consumer group, describes mediation as fast and relatively cheap compared to a lawsuit. Treat any mediation as a negotiation: you go in with documents, a clear number and a clear bottom line.

The choice: which one for your situation?
Use these questions.
1. Is coverage admitted? If the insurer accepts that the loss is covered and only the amount is in dispute, appraisal fits. If coverage is contested, appraisal is not designed to settle it. The Florida DFS guide states that appraisal addresses amount-of-loss disputes but not coverage disputes.
2. Do you want a final answer, or room to negotiate? Appraisal ends the dispute over the amount, whichever way it falls. Mediation keeps control with you: you can accept, counter or leave.
3. Can you do both? Not always. Florida's guide says that if the policyholder and insurer agree to participate in appraisal, neither can participate in mediation later. Whether your state or policy sets such a limit, find out before you choose.
4. How much is at stake? For a small gap, an appraiser's fee plus half an umpire can eat a large share of the difference. For a full roof replacement, the gap is often large enough to justify the cost.
5. Is the dispute tangled? If there are several issues, such as causation, scope, depreciation and pricing, mediation can address them together, while appraisal handles only the value piece.
| Your situation | Likely fit |
|---|---|
| Insurer covers the claim but pays for repairs when you need replacement | Appraisal |
| Insurer's line-item prices are far below local contractor costs | Appraisal |
| Insurer says damage is wear and tear, not storm damage | Coverage dispute: talk to an attorney; mediation may help |
| Several overlapping issues and you want flexibility | Mediation |
| Insurer is delaying or acting unreasonably | Insurance department complaint or attorney |
If your dispute looks like a denial, a coverage question or possible bad faith, speak with an insurance attorney licensed in South Carolina before taking a binding step. Our guide to insurance bad faith in roofing claims explains the warning signs.
Evidence wins both processes
In an appraisal, the appraisers compare estimates. In mediation, the insurer weighs what it could face if the dispute continues. In both, the side with the better paperwork has the advantage. For a roof claim, that means:
- Dated photos of every slope, flashing, vent, gutter and the interior ceilings.
- A written inspection that identifies hail hits, wind creasing, lifted shingles or other damage by location.
- An itemized repair or replacement estimate that separates materials, labor, tear-off, code-required items and disposal.
- The insurer's own estimate and any letters, so differences can be matched line by line.
- Repair estimates for related damage. If wind also damaged windows or frames, line-by-line pricing such as window frame repair estimates helps show how a documented repair scope should be itemized.
We explain why this matters in why a roofing contractor estimate matters for claims. If depreciation is part of the gap, see how to reclaim depreciated funds. And if you are earlier in the process, the roof damage claim steps show what to do first.
One more point on who speaks for you. Your appraiser must be competent and disinterested under many policies. A roofing contractor is a good source of the inspection and estimate that your appraiser works from, but the appraiser role itself is separate. For the difference between a contractor and a public adjuster, see public adjuster vs. roofer.
Common mistakes
- Missing the deadline. Policy and state clocks differ. Read the clause the day you get a low estimate.
- Appraising a coverage fight. If the insurer says the damage is not covered, a valuation panel may not be able to help.
- Vague instructions. Say exactly what value is being appraised, such as replacement cost or actual cash value. The ABA's guidance shows that unclear instructions can put the award at risk in court.
- Cashing a check too soon. Depositing a settlement check can end rights you might otherwise have, such as the Florida rescission window. Ask before you deposit.
- Waiting while the roof leaks. Delay can add interior damage. Protect the property while the dispute runs. We offer 24/7 emergency roof tarping in the Midlands.
Why we start with the inspection
We see the appraisal-versus-mediation question as a documentation question first. Whichever route you take, the number on the table needs a roof inspection behind it, and the inspection needs to be by someone who knows what storm damage looks like and how it is written up for a claim.
That is why our team includes HAAG-certified inspectors, and why we help homeowners with insurance claims. We give honest repair-versus-replacement guidance: if a repair is enough, we say so, and if the roof needs replacing, we show you why in a written scope you can put in front of your insurer.
We are a veteran-owned contractor, and we run projects with discipline and clear communication. That matters in a dispute, where every date, photo and estimate counts. Before you demand appraisal or sit down in mediation, get your roof inspected and your scope written down.
Ebben
Get your roof scope in writing
If your insurer's estimate does not match the damage you can see, start with an inspection. Exterior Genie serves Lexington, Columbia and the surrounding Midlands with roof repair and replacement, storm damage restoration and insurance claim assistance, with HAAG-certified inspectors on our team. See our storm damage restoration page, or start with a free HAAG inspection and claim help.

We are an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor, and our workmanship carries a lifetime warranty. If your roof needs work now, our roof inspections are the first step.
FAQ
What is the difference between appraisal and arbitration in insurance?
Both produce a binding decision from a third party, but appraisal is narrower. It decides only the amount of a covered loss and is set up by your policy's appraisal clause. Arbitration is a broader process that can decide the whole dispute, when your policy or an agreement requires it. Check your policy for which one it names.
Can I use appraisal and mediation on the same claim?
Sometimes, but not always, and the order can matter. Florida's consumer guide says that once both sides agree to appraisal, mediation is no longer available. Rules in other states vary, so read your policy and ask your state insurance department before you choose.
How much does an insurance appraisal cost?
You typically pay your own appraiser and half of the umpire's cost. Appraiser fees can be a flat amount or a percentage of the award, according to Florida's consumer advocate. Ask for the fee structure in writing before you hire. Mediation costs depend on your state's program: in Florida, the insurer pays the $350 conference fee.
Does appraisal decide whether my roof damage is covered?
Generally no. Appraisal decides the amount of a loss. Questions about coverage, exclusions and policy interpretation are normally left to the courts. If your insurer denied the claim, talk with an insurance attorney licensed in South Carolina about your options.
Is mediation binding?
No, mediation itself is non-binding, and you can decline any offer. A settlement you sign is a different matter: it generally binds you. Some states, such as Florida, give a short window to rescind a residential settlement, but check whether yours does.
Sources
- Florida DFS: Alternative Dispute Resolution Options
- Florida DFS: Mediation and Neutral Evaluation
- Florida DFS: Insurance Professionals, Full Coverage
- Florida Statutes 627.7015 (2026)
- Texas Department of Insurance: What if my insurance isn't paying enough?
- American Bar Association: Appraisals, Resolving Disputes over Valuing the Amount of Loss
- United Policyholders: Resolving Claim Disputes
- KKP: Insurance Appraisal Clause and Process
- Washington RCW 48.18.620
- Window Frame Repairs: Your 2026 Auckland Guide
